Shifting sands – how bank managers have joined the alternative finance boom
While many SMEs are worried about the transforming banking landscape, business leaders need not fear that all the experts are disappearing – they may just have to look elsewhere to find them.
Banking has changed beyond all recognition over the last decade, following the Crash. Many high streets are now without a traditional bank as, according to The Times, some 802 branches closed in 2017 alone – a figure that seems certain to accelerate this year.
The statistics continue to stack up: a 2016 report from the Federation of Small Businesses estimated that 1,500 previously banked towns had become branchless; banks are compensating for the loss of these branches by increasingly channeling customers down digital routes. While numerous small businesses are embracing the shift to digital services, with 94% of SMEs using internet banking, there is still huge value in being able to have a face-to-face conversation. This is particularly true when businesses are making important decisions about the future and are looking to raise finance.
Raw, online data may be universally accessible, but an online app cannot back up the figures with years of finance knowledge, no matter how sophisticated the software. The loss of bank managers from many high streets has also seen the disappearance of the experience needed to quantify the different types of funding needed to take an SME to the next stage of its development. The relationships, and the businesses that rely on them, are being lost.
The figures back this up; a recent report from Close Brothers, the merchant-banking group, showed that some 12% of lenders didn’t understand the sector and a further one in ten don’t have the necessary knowledge or understanding of borrower’s individual needs. Hardly surprising, then, that the same report says that only a fifth of SMEs believe bank’s advice always meets their needs.
Data mining is an invaluable tool, and algorithms produce data on a scale never seen before; but there is certainly more to lending than producing endless data – and it involves a human being becoming embedded in a borrowers’ business, nosing around the factory floor, getting to know the different personalities and the management team, and ultimately coming up with a bespoke financial package that will meet the ambitions of that company.
The good news is that many of the most experienced bankers have moved into the alternative finance sector. These experienced lenders have switched their knowledge and experience to more agile organisations operating in the alternative funding and commercial finance sectors. This creates the perfect environment for finance-hungry SMEs who can take advantage of a range of funders offering personal and professional services with great local and industry knowledge – all without the overhead costs and bureaucracy of the traditional lenders.
ThinCats’ origination team is made up of many a seasoned ex-banker, with an average of 20 years’ experience across the team. Their personal experiences reflect the trend:
Andrew Tapsell, business originator, South coast, said:
“From the networking and professional groups that I’ve been to in recent weeks, the absence of any bank representatives has been increasingly noted by the accountants and advisors. Businesses that I have spoken to say that they have approached their bank for finance and are either told that the bank doesn’t have appetite in the sector, or they don’t hear back at all.”
Alison Whistance, business originator, Wales & M4 corridor, said:
“I have seen a lot of change over recent years; with local bank manager autonomy stripped away, many companies struggle to access funding to grow and evolve. With advancing technology and changing buying habits, it is imperative to adapt and invest quickly, but traditional methods of lending seem increasingly restricted. The alternative lending market continues to grow and is playing a vital role supporting UK SMEs.”
Former bank managers have also found alternative employment at accountancy practices and corporate finance advisors who work in partnership with alternative finance providers, ensuring a virtuous circle of knowledge throughout a lending deal that SMEs are more than happy to tap into.
This shift towards alternative finance means that SME owners can now access flexible funding that reflects the specific needs of their business. Deals can be considered on their own merits, and different types of security can be considered to provide collateral. For lenders providing secured loans this doesn’t necessarily have to mean physical assets, as stable and diverse cashflow can also be valuable.
For years now, SME owners have complained that they can’t access their bank manager. Now, aIternative finance providers are heralding the return of a genuine, personal relationship with local business experts, who invest their knowledge and time in their clients’ business growth (a role that the banks have long since eschewed) to put their considerable expertise to good use – supporting SMEs.