The Milburn report’s ambitions are good, but its proposals may not be reality proof
The Milburn report’s ambitions are good, but its proposals may not be reality proof, say leading audit, tax and business advisory firm, Blick Rothenberg.
Robert Salter, a director at the firm, said: “While Alan Milburn’s ambition for future spending to be increasingly focussed on the training & development of young people rather than simply social benefits is good, his proposals may not hold up to reality.”
He added: “For example, Mr Milburn’s proposal to broadly double the number of young people in apprenticeships may not achieve what he is hoping for. About 36% of all young apprentices fail to complete their training programmes – it has to be questioned therefore whether simply doubling the number of apprentice places could just compound this problem.”
Robert said: “Creating a legal duty for schools to provide their pupils with work experience will not achieve much by itself. Currently, there are not enough work experience opportunities for those in further education and studying courses such as BTECs and T Levels, where the work experience is often a compulsory part of their overall qualification. Therefore, simply creating a legal duty for schools to ensure that their pupils have meaningful work experience won’t change this reality.”
He added: “However, the proposal to reduce employer National Insurance Contribution (NIC) costs would be welcomed by many employers, as there is little doubt that the increase in NIC costs from April 2025 has made them increasingly cautious about hiring, particularly young people with little experience. But without an increase in overall vacancies, the problem of unemployment could simply be shifted along the age demographic to older workers.”
Robert said: “The report highlights a number of significant and complex problems for the government to address, spanning from when young people first enter the education system, to when they leave it. Resolving the UK’s Not in Education, Employment, or Training (NEET) problem will be a long-term challenge with no easy answers. Although the Milburn report is a welcome attempt to address them, it does not – by itself – provide a realistic way forward.”


